登陆注册
15752600000088

第88章

The definite theories of jurists are scarcely nearer the truth in this point than the opinions of the multitude. To begin with the views of the Roman lawyers, we find them inconsistent with the true history of moral and legal progress. One class of contracts, in which the plighted faith of the contracting parties was the only material ingredient, they specifically denominated Contracts juris gentium, and though these contracts were undoubtedly the latest born into the Roman system, the expression employed implies, if a definite meaning be extracted from it, that they were more ancient than certain other forms of engagement treated of in Roman law, in which the neglect of a mere technical formality was as fatal to the obligation as misunderstanding or deceit. But then the antiquity to which they were referred was vague, shadowy, and only capable of being understood through the Present; nor was it until the language of the Roman lawyers became the language of an age which had lost the key to their mode of thought that a "Contract of the Law of Nations" came to be distinctly looked upon as a Contract known to man in a State of Nature. Rousseau adopted both the juridical and the popular error. In the Dissertation on the effects of Art and Science upon Morals, the first of his works which attracted attention and the one in which he states most unreservedly the opinions which made him the founder of a sect, the veracity and good faith attributed to the ancient Persians are repeatedly pointed out as traits of primitive innocence which have been gradually obliterated by civilisation; and at a later period he found a basis for all his speculations in the doctrine of an original Social Contract. The Social Contract or Compact is the most systematic form which has ever been assumed by the error we are discussing. It is a theory which, though nursed into importance by political passions, derived all its sap from the speculations of lawyers. True it certainly is that the famous Englishmen, for whom it had first had attraction, valued it chiefly for its political serviceableness, but, as I shall presently attempt to explain, they would never have arrived at it, if politicians had not long conducted their controversies in legal phraseology. Nor were the English authors of the theory blind to that speculative amplitude which recommended it so strongly to the Frenchmen who inherited it from them. Their writings show they perceived that it could be made to account for all social, quite as well as for all political phenomena. They had observed the fact, already striking in their day, that of the positive rules obeyed by men, the greater part were created by Contract, the lesser by Imperative Law. But they were ignorant or careless of the historical relation of these two constituents of jurisprudence. It was for the purpose, therefore, of gratifying their speculative tastes by attributing all jurisprudence to a uniform source, as much as with the view of eluding the doctrines which claimed a divine parentage for Imperative Law that they devised the theory that all Law had its origin in Contract. In another stage of thought, they would have been satisfied to leave their theory in the condition of an ingenious hypothesis or a convenient verbal formula. But that age was under the dominion of legal superstitions. The State of Nature had been talked about till it had ceased to be regarded as paradoxical, and hence it seemed easy to give a fallacious reality and definiteness to the contractual origin of Law by insisting on the Social Compact as a historical fact.

Our own generation has got rid of these erroneous juridical theories, partly by outgrowing the intellectual state to which they belong, and partly by almost ceasing to theorise on such subjects altogether. The favourite occupation of active minds at the present moment, and the one which answers to the speculations of our forefathers on the origin of the social state, is the analysis of society as it exists and moves before our eyes; but, through omitting to call in the assistance of history, this analysis too often degenerates into an idle exercise of curiosity, and is especially apt to incapacitate the inquirer for comprehending states of society which differ considerably from that to which he is accustomed. The mistake of judging the men of other periods by the morality of our own day has its parallel in the mistake of supposing that every wheel and bolt in the modern social machine had its counterpart in more rudimentary societies.

Such impressions ramify very widely, and masque themselves very subtly, in historical works written in the modern fashion; but Ifind the trace of their presence in the domain of jurisprudence in the praise which is frequently bestowed on the little apologue of Montesquieu concerning the Troglodytes, inserted in the Lettres Persanes. The Troglodytes were a people who systematically violated their Contracts, and so perished utterly.

同类推荐
热门推荐
  • 碎碎念之末夏

    碎碎念之末夏

    等到了夏天,或许才会发现自己是多么喜欢冬天。即使太阳很是耀眼,却不能温暖我的心。“本以为这一生,我是你的所有,你是我的所有,却不想这话是多么的可笑。初恋对于每个人来说,都应该是美好的吧,难忘的吧,事实如此!所以,你记起了她,忘了我,而我却还是念着你。直到最后,我再也没有说过你别走这种可笑的话!”一封信,末了所有。“让我从帆布鞋陪你到高跟鞋,却不曾想,高跟鞋碎了一地!”撞在一起的缘分,只是有缘无分罢了。其实,许多事从一开始就已经感到了结局,往后所有的折腾,都不过只是为了拖延散场的时间而已!
  • 我跟三国抢天下

    我跟三国抢天下

    朦胧的誓言:记得那年冬天,我们彼此陪伴,穿越了三国,征战是唯一的火焰,我们一起点燃,我们长发披肩,冷冷的旷野荒芜人烟,有兄弟,还有烈酒,就能取暖,还记得二十年前,那两个懵懂的少年穿上了铠甲,挺起了双肩,盼望三国梦想能实现,多少当年的三国英雄。二十年后早已不见,而我们但还为此一战,因为三国还在继续,就算已雄踞西凉,彼此却坚信总有一天会像神话一样活到2016,就在这二十年前,这世界悄悄的改变,穿越了三国,苍老的容颜,命运就此断念。
  • 缘到福来

    缘到福来

    这是一个不知道未来会怎么发展的故事...【神秘】
  • 无极掌控

    无极掌控

    江湖路,人生途。修五行,练阴阳;化混沌,筑乾坤。五行八卦在身侧,混沌阴阳皆归吾。
  • 花千骨之一生画骨峰

    花千骨之一生画骨峰

    【画骨峰】前世她是调皮可爱又聪明的花千骨,为白子画付出了所有,最后落得生不如死的下场。她在临死前说:如果有来世,但愿不要再相遇你。他是冷漠无情的长留上仙白子画,本可以为爱不顾一切却还是选择了放下,执念太深。在她临死之前她对他的惩罚:白子画,我以神的名义诅咒你。今生今世,永生永世;不老不死,不伤不灭!今生的他们会是怎样的结果?是否还会像前世一样的遭遇?【梦梦最近好累,没心里没头脑了。更文有时会慢些,请大家谅解!我是爱你们哒,摸摸哒~o(〃'▽'〃)o……】
  • 离火炼器师

    离火炼器师

    生死之间走过两三个来回,大难不死的杨骏考虑生死的意义。超越仙灵的离火之气,吞噬一切的毁天炎帝,杀神戮仙的上古神兵。这是一个俗子以炼器封神的传奇之路。他不再是那个小工匠,他是所有人的主宰!
  • 美少女择草记

    美少女择草记

    哈!美貌、智慧,财富。唉!面前竟然冒出个又拽又穷的坏小子。吼!无视、嘲笑,最最最可恨的是,这家伙竟是齐北NO.1的校草。切!不要以为帅了点,做事执着了点,我对你又愧疚了点,我就会选你这根狗尾草哦。看!还有另一株校草呢。
  • 世界最具财富性的企业精英(5)

    世界最具财富性的企业精英(5)

    我的课外第一本书——震撼心灵阅读之旅经典文库,《阅读文库》编委会编。通过各种形式的故事和语言,讲述我们在成长中需要的知识。
  • 爱之裂痕

    爱之裂痕

    一切以爱之名的罪恶,都来自人心的贪婪不计后果的爱,彼此伤害的家人唯一剩下的,只有一片废墟绝望的人生不再有一丝阳光原来一切都可以不一样只是悔之已晚
  • 一件长衬衣,一个夏天

    一件长衬衣,一个夏天

    故事男主角叶岚清在结束高考后,开始了暑假打工的生活。不经意间,他偶然遇到了暗恋的同龄人网络主播小豆。原本只是虚无的存在于电子屏幕上的精神寄托忽然落实到现实生活中来,没有恋爱经验的叶岚清忽地一下子不知所措,丑态百出,令小豆生厌。当他苦苦陷于幻梦破灭的失恋焦虑中时,他却不知道,自己早就落入了小豆和网友们给他下的一个套。直到他最后不顾一切地奋力一搏,事情才有了戏剧性的转机。