登陆注册
15339200000048

第48章 Fallacies

Right understanding consists in the discovery and adherence to truth,and that in the perception of the visible or probable agreement or disagreement of ideas as they are affirmed and denied one of another.From whence it is evident that the right use and conduct of the understanding,w hose business is purely truth and nothing else,is that the mind should be kept in a perfect indifference,not inclining to either side any further than evidence settles it by knowledge or the over-balance of probability gives it the turn of assent and belief;but yet it is very hard to meet with any discourse wherein one may not perceive the author not only maintain (for that is reasonable and fit),but inclined and biased to one side of the question With marks of a desire that should be true.

If it be asked me how authors who have such a bias and lean to it may be discovered,I answer,by observing how in their Writings or arguings they are often led by their inclinations to change the ideas of the question,either by changing the terms or by adding and joining others to them,whereby the ideas under consideration are so varied as to be more serviceable to their purpose and to be thereby brought to an easier and nearer agreement or more visible and remoter disagreement one with another.This is plain and direct sophistry;but I am far from thinking that,wherever it is found,it is made use of with design to deceive and mislead the readers.

It is visible that men's prejudices and inclinations by this way impose often upon themselves;and their affection for truth,under their prepossession in favor of one side,is the very thing that leads them from it.Inclination suggests and slides into their discourse favorable terms which introduce favorable ideas,till at last by this means that is concluded clear and evident,thus dressed up,which taken in its native state,by making use of none but the precise determined ideas,would find no admittance at all.

The putting these glosses on what they affirm,these (as they are thought)handsome,easy and graceful explications of what they are discoursing on,is so much the character of what is called and esteemed writing well,that it is very hard to think that authors will ever be persuaded to leave what serves so well to propagate their opinions and procure themselves credit in the world for a more jejune and dry way of writing,by keeping to the same terms precisely annexed to the same ideas,a sour and blunt stiffness tolerable in mathematicians only,who force their way and make truth prevail by irresistible demonstration.

But yet,if authors cannot be prevailed with to quit the looser,though more insinuating,ways of writing,if they will not think fit to keep close to truth and instruction by unvaried terms and plain unsophisticated arguments,yet it concerns readers not to be imposed on by fallacies and the prevailing ways of insinuation.To do this,the surest and most effectual remedy is to fix in the mind the clear and distinct ideas of the question stripped of words;and so likewise in the train of argumentation,to take up the author's ideas,neglecting his words,observing how they connect or separate those in the question.He that does this will be able to cast off all that is superfluous;he will see what is pertinent,what coherent,what is direct to,what slides by the question.This will readily show him all the foreign ideas in the discourse and where they were brought in;and though they perhaps dazzled the writer,yet he will perceive that they give no light nor strength to his reasonings.

This,though it be the shortest and easiest way of reading books with profit and keeping oneself from being misled by great names or plausible discourses,yet,it being hard and tedious to those who have not accustomed themselves to it,it is not to be expected that everyone (amongst those few who really pursue truth)should this way guard his understanding from being imposed on by the willful or at least undesigned sophistry which creeps into most of the books of argument.They that write against their conviction or that,next to them,are resolved to maintain the tenets of a party they are engaged in cannot be supposed to reject any arms that may help to defend their cause,and therefore such should be read with the greatest caution.And they who write for opinions they are sincerely persuaded of and believe to be true think they may so far allow themselves to indulge their laudable affection to truth as to permit their esteem of it to give it the best colors and set it off with the best expressions and dress they can,thereby to gain it the easiest entrance into the minds of their readers and fix it deepest there.

One of those being the state of mind we may justly suppose most writers to be in,it is fit their readers,who apply to them for instruction,should not lay by that caution which becomes a sincere pursuit of truth,and should make them always watchful against whatever might conceal or misrepresent it.If they have not the skill of representing to themselves the author's sense by pure ideas separated from sounds and thereby divested of the false lights and deceitful ornaments of speech,this yet they should do:they should keep the precise question steadily in their minds,carry it along Faith them through the whole discourse,and suffer not the least alteration in the terms either by addition,subtraction or substituting any other.This everyone can do who has a mind to it;and he that has not a mind to it,it is plain makes his understanding only the warehouse of other men's lumber?Imean false and unconcluding reasonings,rather than a repository of truth for his own use,which will prove substantial and stand him in stead when he has occasion for it.And whether such a one deals fairly by his own mind and conducts his own understanding right,I leave to his own understanding to judge.

同类推荐
  • 搜神记句道兴本

    搜神记句道兴本

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 净土证心集

    净土证心集

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 烈皇小识

    烈皇小识

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 部执异论

    部执异论

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 苕溪渔隐词话

    苕溪渔隐词话

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
热门推荐
  • 暖情速递:闫总,真爱包邮

    暖情速递:闫总,真爱包邮

    发现老公出轨后,林微安依然决定离婚。戏剧性的是,离婚当天她才知道自己怀孕了,更戏剧的是,她的出轨老公在民政局门口出了车祸,当场死亡。虽然渣男已死,可她的悲惨命运也才刚刚开始。恶毒的前公婆,得知她怀的是儿子后,随时都要抢回去。而她的亲生父亲胆小懦弱,跟继母想尽各种方式压榨她。亲生母亲却一直不肯认她,一出现就要让她打掉孩子,为的就是要林微安捐出肝脏救她。好在极品众多的生活中,始终有一个人一直站在她身边,宠她爱她呵护她,让她安稳度日。
  • 妖怪实录影

    妖怪实录影

    为了追溯自己的过去,少年毅然选择激发自己的血脉。踏上寻找自己身世的旅途,驱妖师的血脉,妖怪的鬼影,一切的一切的一切,是你的救赎,还是我的审判?驱妖之后,我的泪,为谁流?
  • 执掌大罗

    执掌大罗

    作为一个随时可能消散的新死之鬼,穆青自封成神,穿梭三千世界,无量星辰,一步步走上了执掌诸天大罗的道路。什么是真相,前路在何处......这是一个没有金手指帮助,孤身驰入星辰大海,困难重重,披荆斩棘的道路。一本集合了武侠、穿越、玄学、修真、死神空间、魔法的大杂烩。
  • 仙武霸途

    仙武霸途

    天生无经脉是废材吗?在哥眼中却是神级天赋。穿越中获得远古昊天大帝百万年武道记忆的萧羽,谈笑间俘获无数芳心,举手间震慑一片虾米,投足间踩倒一群大咖。逆天而上的传奇之旅,仙武霸途的画卷徐徐展开!
  • 武神不爱江山

    武神不爱江山

    商人林海重生到异世大陆,那是一个强者为尊的世界。借尸还魂的他,不再是四十多岁的成熟大叔,而是一个乳臭未干的小猎人。本以为自己会一直待在那个宁静的小山村,结果却走上了成神的道路。白云苍狗,沧海桑田,越走越远的林海不忘初心——若我成神,坐拥天下。不爱江山,爱美人。
  • 豪门宠妻:钟总裁的美人鱼

    豪门宠妻:钟总裁的美人鱼

    毛里求斯的海岸,她对她一见钟情。家破人亡之际,他像救世主一样救了她。爱到无法自拔之时,他却狠心背叛。美人鱼将刀口刺向自己,最终,王子却真的忘了她。某男,“女人,你在找死?”某女冷哼,“没有你,我活着做什么?”“当初他为了我,连命都可以不计较,我又怎么会计较他忘了我。”“墨寒,我的人生,就是一场华丽陨落的流星,幸而有你,流星变成了美好的愿望。”“墨寒,如果不曾爱过你,我还可以爱别人。可惜没不曾。”“墨寒,你还能不能想起我,你还有没有可能……再爱我。”“墨寒,我累了,好像有点……爱不动了。”钟墨寒,“如果你累了,那,换我来爱你。”
  • 爱情萌萌哒

    爱情萌萌哒

    “啊,你是谁啊,你对我做了什么?”“你这个流~氓——”“我告诉你,你要是再接近我,我就咬舌自尽——”“陈子阳,你就是个大坏蛋——”“我,何千千,一定会嫁给陈子阳——”蓝色的天空渐渐变得灰白,男人的笑容凝固在俊美的脸上——“不要——”整个空间都回荡着凄凉的喊声——如果还有来世,我希望能早一点遇到你,如果有来世,我希望我们能一起看日出日落,如果有来世,我希望,执子之手,与子偕老,终身不离,永生不弃——功夫女主与邪魅地皇的极致之恋,请大家多多支持,文文是新风格,望支持,翘首盼评论收藏。
  • EXO之愿一切都好灿白

    EXO之愿一切都好灿白

    主灿白。其他人都会有客串。校园内的奇妙之旅''''''''''''''伯贤姐姐和世勋还会有奇妙的碰触哦
  • 华年以伤

    华年以伤

    有关爱情,有关青春,没人能说自己的青春没有遗憾,只能说自己在尽力实现减少遗憾。高三那年,许安听见了最动人的告白,也许明天还不能确定,但是这一刻有你就够了!
  • 我的无限水晶宫

    我的无限水晶宫

    本书已经转到贝塔的好朋友,正在审核中,欢迎新老读者前去捧场。