登陆注册
15325700000001

第1章

Paris, January 23, 1656SIR, We were entirely mistaken.It was only yesterday that I was undeceived.Until that time I had laboured under the impression that the disputes in the Sorbonne were vastly important, and deeply affected the interests of religion.The frequent convocations of an assembly so illustrious as that of the Theological Faculty of Paris, attended by so many extraordinary and unprecedented circumstances, led one to form such high expectations that it was impossible to help coming to the conclusion that the subject was most extraordinary.

You will be greatly surprised, however, when you learn from the following account the issue of this grand demonstration, which, having made myself perfectly master of the subject, I shall be able to tell you in very few words.

Two questions, then, were brought under examination; the one a question of fact, the other a question of right.

The question of fact consisted in ascertaining whether M.

Arnauld was guilty of presumption, for having asserted in his second letter that he had carefully perused the book of Jansenius, and that he had not discovered the propositions condemned by the late pope; but that, nevertheless, as he condemned these propositions wherever they might occur, he condemned them in Jansenius, if they were really contained in that work.

The question here was, if he could, without presumption, entertain a doubt that these propositions were in Jansenius, after the bishops had declared that they were.

The matter having been brought before the Sorbonne, seventy-one doctors undertook his defence, maintaining that the only reply he could possibly give to the demands made upon him in so many publications, calling on him to say if he held that these propositions were in that book, was that he had not been able to find them, but that if they were in the book, he condemned them in the book.

Some even went a step farther and protested that, after all the search they had made into the book, they had never stumbled upon these propositions, and that they had, on the contrary, found sentiments entirely at variance with them.They then earnestly begged that, if any doctor present had discovered them, he would have the goodness to point them out; adding that what was so easy could not reasonably be refused, as this would be the surest way to silence the whole of them, M.Arnauld included; but this proposal has been uniformly declined.So much for the one side.

On the other side are eighty secular doctors and some forty mendicant friars, who have condemned M.Arnauld's proposition, without choosing to examine whether he has spoken truly or falsely- who, in fact, have declared that they have nothing to do with the veracity of his proposition, but simply with its temerity.

Besides these, there were fifteen who were not in favor of the censure, and who are called Neutrals.

Such was the issue of the question of fact, regarding which, Imust say, I give myself very little concern.It does not affect my conscience in the least whether M.Arnauld is presumptuous or the reverse; and should I be tempted, from curiosity, to ascertain whether these propositions are contained in Jansenius, his book is neither so very rare nor so very large as to hinder me from reading it over from beginning to end, for my own satisfaction, without consulting the Sorbonne on the matter.

Were it not, however, for the dread of being presumptuous myself, I really think that I would be disposed to adopt the opinion which has been formed by the most of my acquaintances, who, though they have believed hitherto on common report that the propositions were in Jansenius, begin now to suspect the contrary, owing to this strange refusal to point them out- a refusal the more extraordinary to me as I have not yet met with a single individual who can say that he has discovered them in that work.I am afraid, therefore, that this censure will do more harm than good, and that the impression which it will leave on the minds of all who know its history will be just the reverse of the conclusion that has been come to.The truth is the world has become sceptical of late and will not believe things till it sees them.But, as I said before, this point is of very little moment, as it has no concern with religion.

The question of right, from its affecting the faith, appears much more important, and, accordingly, I took particular pains in examining it.You will be relieved, however, to find that it is of as little consequence as the former.

The point of dispute here was an assertion of M.Arnauld's in the same letter, to the effect "that the grace, without which we can do nothing, was wanting to St.Peter at his fall." You and Isupposed that the controversy here would turn upon the great principles of grace; such as whether grace is given to all men? Or if it is efficacious of itself? But we were quite mistaken.You must know I have become a great theologian within this short time; and now for the proofs of it!

同类推荐
热门推荐
  • 冷情校草是女神

    冷情校草是女神

    “和我在一起!”“我是男人……”“没关系,我不介意gay”“……”那一年,她销声匿迹地悄无声息,从此杳无音讯。再次相遇,他们都没有认出对方。直到她再一次离开,他发了疯般的满世界寻找她。他将她禁锢在怀。“放手!”“你以为我还会轻而易举地放开你?”男强女强,因剧情需要,会带点小小小小虐。不会浪费太多纸巾~爱宠文的亲故们也可以尽情入坑!
  • 死猪不怕开水烫

    死猪不怕开水烫

    这是一个女小强被骗婚到山里后,才发现自己的男人不能人道,男方家长想留住女小强,让小叔子代兄履行丈夫义务,因为小叔子有家庭,女小强劝小叔子回归了家庭。女小强不甘贫穷,为了改变生存环境,她不断上进,不断学习,先是修路,后又建房,最后还当起了女包工头,虽然困难重重,但她永不放弃的精神贯穿着全文。但由于女主是一个典型的90后,她也具有一些90后的特质,她骂过混混,打过二流子,还用铁钉差点杀了一个风尘女子,她敢作敢当,敢闯敢拼,有置之死地而后生的精神,死猪不怕开水烫的精神,死过了,就无所畏惧了,死过了,就不会怕艰难了,死过了,开水再烫多少遍就都不怕痛了。在女主努力奋斗的过程中,遇到了男主卓景,男主被女小强的精神感动,两人在那个闭塞的乡村,演绎着他们平凡却让人感动的爱情故事。
  • 我和我可爱的室友

    我和我可爱的室友

    主要讲述一个来自乡村的懵懂的女生在高考结束后的暑假生活以及来到大学后宿舍室友间的日常生活,可以很逗,可以很“恐怖”,可以很烦恼,悲欢离合喜怒无常的大学生活需要亲们来细细品味……
  • 极品凰女太轻狂

    极品凰女太轻狂

    她是一个穿越到异世被家族背叛而被外祖母家接受的孩子。一朝灵力觉醒,看她如何搅拌异世风云!看医毒双绝的她如何活死人肉白骨!背叛她的,虽强必诛!她在异世混的风生水起的,可是,这谁能告诉她这个绝世的男人怎么那么霸道?
  • 道家真人异界游

    道家真人异界游

    道家始祖灵宝天尊座下弟子,在度圣劫之时,因命数一劫,机缘巧合之下却穿越到异界,展开了一段段精彩的故事....
  • 配角升职手册

    配角升职手册

    何辜于天?我罪伊何?心之忧矣,云如之何?――苍天啊,我究竟犯了何罪,你要如此折磨于我。我死的离奇不说,每个世界还总有人想对我……望着后面一团黑影,糟糕,不说话,赶紧逃……
  • 咒血风云

    咒血风云

    少年云驰遭受上天的诅咒,为了摆脱命运的安排,开始了与天争命的传奇人生。天地不仁,以万物为粪土,按理当诛;大道无情,视众生为蝼蚁,论罪当伐!咒血燃烧,洗尽天地铅华;真情澎湃,武动世间风云。且看他如何崩碎不朽的棋局,屠灭永恒的主宰,将天地万道踩在脚下。
  • 登天之塔

    登天之塔

    一座没有尽头的塔。或者,塔只是无数种形式的一种。但是,所有能进入此塔的人都会有一翻惊心动魄的际遇。
  • 未曾想

    未曾想

    江洋羊太卑微,自己喜欢的人太优秀,也喜欢着另外一个非常优秀的女孩。她爱到深处终究会失去理智。爱与不爱,配于不配,自己也不知道。未曾想过自己会爱他这么深,未曾想过自己会为了爱情而沉沦,未曾想过……输得这么彻底。
  • 妖孽成双:深情王爷冷情妃

    妖孽成双:深情王爷冷情妃

    她安分守己了一辈子,结果却落得了一个道德沦丧的骂名,被丈夫迫害致死。重生,她怀着满腹仇恨,心心念念只有报复。前世冤家,今生桃花。高深莫测的亲王,邪魅总攻的郡王,冷傲善谋的哥哥……各路美男争着来投怀送抱,谁才是与她执手一生的归宿?